Shelsky's Smoked Fish Service List

Main Menu

• Beverages

  • Ashlawn Farm French-Pressed Coffee

    Starting at

    $2.00

  • Dr. Brown's Soda's

    $1.00

  • Martinelli's Sparkling Apple Cider

    $2.99

  • Manhattan Special Espresso Soda

    $2.00

  • Fizzy Lizzy Sparkling Fruit Juice

    $2.00

• Salads

  • Cucumber Salad

    per lb.

    $5.95

  • Egg Salad

    per lb.

    $8.98

  • Pickled Herring Salad

    per lb.

    $15.98

  • Baked Salmon Salad

    per lb.

    $17.98

  • Citrus Roasted Beet Salad

    per lb.

    $8.98

  • Fancy Tuna Salad

    per lb.

    $14.98

  • Smoked Whitefish Salad

    per lb.

    $17.98

• Guss' Pickles

  • Sour Pickle

    Two half or full sour pickles, or purchase a quart

    Starting at

    $1.00

  • Sauerkraut

    per quart

    $8.00

  • Sour Tomatoes

    per sour tomato

    $1.00

• Breads

  • Orwasher's Ultimate Whole Wheat

    Made with local flours and grains

    $8.00

  • Orwasher's Raisin Pumpernickel

    One Lb.

    $3.75

  • Giant Onion Pocket

  • Kossar's Bialys

    Please contact the restaurant for availability

    Starting at

    $1.00

  • Braided Bagel Challah

    $8.00

  • Orwasher's Rye

    One lb. of either seeded or plain rye

    $3.50

  • Sesame Pane Rustico

    $3.50

  • Kossar's Bagels

    Please contact the restaurant for availability

    Starting at

    $1.00

  • Kossar's Pletzle

    $6.00

• Cold Smoked and Cured Fish

  • Eastern Gaspe Nova

    per 1/4 lb.

    $8.99

  • Irish Double Cured Organic Salmon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $10.49

  • Mild Scottish Salmon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $8.99

  • David Burke Pastrami Salmon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $8.99

  • House-Cured Gravlax

    per 1/4 lb.

    $11.99

  • Cold Smoked Tuna

    per 1/4 lb.

    $13.99

  • Western Wild Salmon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $10.49

  • House-Cured Clementine and Ginger Salmon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $11.99

  • Saltier Scottish Salmon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $10.49

  • Belly Lox

    per 1/4 lb.

    $8.49

  • Sable (Black Cod)

    per 1/4 lb.

    $14.99

  • Mexican Achiote Cured

    per 1/4 lb.

    $11.99

• Hot Smoked Fish

  • Blue Fish

    per 1/4 lb.

    $5.49

  • Lean Kippered Salmon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $8.99

  • White Fish

    per lb.

    $18.85

  • Kippers

    per lb.

    $11.50

  • Fatty Kippered Salmon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $10.49

  • Fancy Lake Sturgeon

    per 1/4 lb.

    $16.49

  • Bering Cisco

    per lb.

    $23.75

• Herring, Pickled Etc.

  • Herring

    per filet

    $3.25

  • Matjes Herring

    $5.50

  • Pickled Lox

    per 1/4 lb.

    $8.49

  • Roll Mops

    One roll mop

    $3.25

  • Kippered Herring

    $1.50

• Specialty Sandwiches

  • Member of the Tribe Sandwich

    Gaspe nova with scallion or plain cream cheese and served on a bagel or bialy. Please call restaurant for availability

    $8.50

  • Peter Shelsky Sandwich

    Gaspe nova, sable, pickled herring with cream sauce and onion, and scallion cream cheese all served on a bagel or bialy. Please call restaurant for availability

    $11.50

  • Brooklyn Transplant Sandwich

    Fatty kippered salmon, apple horseradish, cream cheese and pickled herring salad served on pumpernickel or rye bread. Please call restaurant for availability

    $10.50

  • Dr. Goldstein Special Sandwich

    Duck fat laced chopped liver and apple horseradish sauce served between two schmaltz fried potato latkes. Please call restaurant for availability

    $9.50

  • Sweet and Smokey Blintz Sandwich

    Lean kippered salmon, apples, red onions and horseradish creme fraiche rolled in a crepe. Please call restaurant for availability

    $6.60

  • Brooklyn Native Sandwich

    Gaspe nova, smoked whitefish salad, pickled herring and sour pickle served on a bagel or bialy. Please call restaurant for availability

    $10.50

  • Shelsky's Pastrami Sandwich

    Pastrami salmon, mustard herring and Riesling braised sauerkraut, served on pumpernickel or rye. Please call restaurant for availability

    $10.50

  • The Tribute Sandwich

    Horseradish cream cheese, smoked whitefish salad and wasabi tobiko. Please call restaurant for availability

    $12.50

• Sweets and Homemade Baked Goods

  • Mama Ilene's Coconut Macaroons

  • Lingonberry and Toasted Spiced Pumpkin Seed Rugelach

    per lb.

    $14.50

  • Chocolate and Cinnamon Babka

    per lb.

    $9.50

  • Chocolate Covered Vanilla Marshmallow Twists

    per lb.

    $8.50

  • Rugelach

    per lb.

    $14.50

  • Clementine and Ginger Rugelach

    per lb.

    $14.50

  • Chocolate Covered Jelly Rings

    per lb.

    $8.50

  • Halvah Bars

    $2.50

• Jarred Items

  • Sarabeth's Peach Apricot Preserves

    $9.99

  • Sarabeth's Strawberry and Raspberry Preserves

    $9.99

  • Manischewitz Sweet Gefilte Fish

    $9.99

  • BF Salt Packed Capers

    $4.99

  • Brooklyn Brine Whiskey Sour Pickles

    $10.00

  • Brooklyn Brine Lavender Pickled Asparagus

    $10.00

  • Linda Caperberries

    $3.79

  • Wild Hibiscus Flowers in Syrup

    $10.00

  • Portuguese Spicy Sardines in Olive Oil

    $3.75

  • Ortiz Yellow Fin Tuna Jars

    $12.00

  • Think Pink Canned Salmon

    $3.75

  • Reniero Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil

    $13.79

  • Sarabeth's Blood Orange Marmalade

    $9.99

  • Manischewitz Premium Gold Gefilte Fish

    $9.99

  • Manischewitz Jarred Borscht with Diced Beets

    $3.99

  • BF Capers in Brine

    $3.99

  • Brooklyn Brine Damn Spicy Pickles

    $10.00

  • Brooklyn Brine Fennel Beets

    $10.00

  • Honeycup Honey Mustard

    $6.49

  • Portuguese Sardines in Olive Oil

    $3.75

  • Portuguese Sardines in Tomato Sauce

    $3.75

  • Red Head Canned Salmon

    $6.25

  • Unio Extra Virgin Olive Oil

    $16.99

• Boxed and Bagged Items

  • Tam Tam Original Crackers

    $4.99

  • Carrs Cracked Pepper Crackers

    $4.50

  • Macy's Cheese Sticks

    $4.00

  • David's Kosher Salt

    $1.99

  • Mashuga Nuts Double Chocolate Walnuts

    2.5 Oz.

    $4.99

  • Streitz Matzo Meal

    $3.99

  • Carrs Sesame Water Crackers

    $4.50

  • Plain Bremner Wafers

    $3.75

  • Diamond Crystal Kosher Salt

    $4.99

  • Mashuga Nuts Sweet and Salty Pecans

    Starting at

    $4.49

  • Manischewitz Wide Egg Noodles

    $3.49

  • Streitz Matzo

    $3.99

• Ashlawn Farm Organic Coffee

  • Captain Bill's Bold Blend (Whole Bean)

    $12.00

  • 1730 Blend (Whole Bean)

    $12.00

  • Decaf French Roast (Ground)

    $12.50

  • Captain Bill's Bold Blend (Ground)

    $12.50

  • 1730 Blend (Ground)

    $12.50