230 Grand St
50 E Broadway Frnt 1
130 Division St
295 Grand St
153 Centre St
64 Bayard St





(two traditional rich, flaky, tender crusts; top and bottom); each serves 6-8
Apple
An all-American classic brimming with tart Granny Smith apples lightly scented with cinnamon
| $25.00 |
Peach
Juicy, tree-ripened fruit; absolutely scrumptious
| $25.00 |
Blueberry
Delicious local blueberries; the best ever! Sweet and simple
| $26.00 |
Peach Raspberry
Our peach pie, studded with fresh summer raspberries. Yum!
| $28.00 |
(beautiful latticework top, traditional full bottom crust); serves 6-8. Serve the below pies at room temperature or warmed with a dollop of vanilla ice cream!
Cherry
Luscious! A sensuous balance of sweet and tart
| $28.00 |
Strawberry Rhubarb
An old-fashioned and never-fail combination
| $26.00 |
(brown sugar and honey streusel on top, flaky pie crust on bottom); each serves 6-8. Serve the above pies at room temperature or warmed with a dollop of ice cream!
Apple Crumb
Crisp Granny Smith apples made sweet, then touched with cinnamon
| $25.00 |
Peach Crumb
Summer at its very best! Peach perfection
| $25.00 |
Blueberry Crumb
Local berries bursting with flavor. A great picnic dessert
| $26.00 |
Mixed Berry Crumb
Best of the season: blueberries, raspberries, blackberries, strawberries
| $30.00 |
Cherry Crumb
Red tart cherries, delectable with streusel topping
| $28.00 |
8" Lemon Meringue Pie
Our famous, tangy lemon curd, topped with a light, mesmerizing meringue and baked in a delicious, tender, flaky crust. Serve cold for a refreshing summer treat!
| $28.00 |
A different pricing scale applies to tiered and sculpted cakes. Sculpted cakes begin at $10 per portion, with a minimum of $250
Half Sheet
Serves 40-50
Starting At | $140.00 |
Full Sheet
Serves 100-125
Starting At | $225.00 |
6" Cake
Serves 6-8
Starting At | $38.00 |
8" Cake
Serves 10-14
Starting At | $48.00 |
9" Cake
Serves 16-20
Starting At | $60.00 |
10" Cake
Serves 18-24
Starting At | $70.00 |
12" Cake
Serves 28-40
Starting At | $85.00 |
14" Cake
Serves 48-60
Starting At | $125.00 |
16" Cake
Serves 70-90
Starting At | $160.00 |
18" Cake
Serves 100-125
Starting At | $225.00 |
6" Cake
Serves 8-10
Starting At | $48.00 |
8" Cake
Serves 12-18
Starting At | $58.00 |
9" Cake
Serves 18-24
Starting At | $70.00 |
10" Cake
Serves 24-30
Starting At | $80.00 |
12" Cake
Serves 36-50
Starting At | $105.00 |
14" Cake
Serves 48-70
Starting At | $140.00 |
16" Cake
Serves 80-100
Starting At | $175.00 |
18" Cake
Serves 100-150
Starting At | $250.00 |
Tiered Cakes & Wedding Cakes
We will help you create the cake of your dreams! And we offer a variety of cake, filling and icing flavors to make that happen. Prices are determined by the complexity of the design, ranging from $6 to $15 per portion. We have an extensive photo collection of styles and decorations as examples and for inspiration or we can work together to fashion a custom design. Be sure to browse our picture gallery of Tiered Cakes & Wedding Cakes by clicking on the links to the left
Custom Cookies
Our custom cookies are edible works of art - a tasty addition to any celebration, party or special event. All of our cookies are handmade and individually decorated. Choose from traditional sugar cookies, thin tuiles or gingerbread. We have a vast collection of cookie cutters or talk to us about creating unique cookie shapes for personalized designs or recreating company logos or special insignias. Prices begin at $3.50 per cookie. There is a minimum of one dozen (12) cookies for any special order. Be sure to browse our picture gallery of Custom Cookies by clicking on the links to the left
Petits Fours
"Small glazed cakes" - are an elegant and delicious addition to any affair. Our petits fours are made with two layers of cake and one layer of filling then iced with poured fondant. We can make many shapes and can customize the decoration to suit your event. Prices begin at $3 per petits four. There is a minimum order of one dozen (12) petits fours per cake flavor. Be sure to browse our gallery of Petits Fours pictures. Check out our Design Your Own Petits Fours. You can customize your petits fours in an infinite number of combinations, ready for pick up or shipping within 48 hours of the time you place your order. Check them out in our online stores for pick up or mail order. Shapes: Round, Square, Oval & Heart Flavors: Almond Pound Cake with Apricot Jam, Almond Pound Cake with Raspberry Jam, Lemon Pound Cake with Lemon Curd, Chocolate Fudge Cake with Chocolate Filling
A perfect party treat. Whether sophisticated, simple or whimsical, we will decorate our cupcakes in any style that makes you happy! For special orders, there is a minimum of one dozen (12) cupcakes per cake flavor. (See cake & cupcake flavors below.) Be sure to browse our gallery of Cupcake pictures. Check out Design Your Own Cupcakes in our online store. Get creative and we'll have them ready in 48 hours. Mini size available too!
Cupcakes
Mini (1 3/4") | $2.50 |
Regular (2 3/4") | $3.50 |
Regular with Filling | $5.00 |
Color Paper Cups
Mini | |
Regular |
Sprinkles, Confetti, Sparkle Sugar
Complimentary
Flowers
buttercream, sugar, chocolate
Mini (Starting At) | $1.00 |
Regular (Starting At) | $2.50 |
Chocolate Curls, Letters, Number
Mini (Starting At) | |
Regular (Starting At) | $1.00 |
Other Custom Decorations
Mini (Starting At) | $2.50 |
Regular (Starting At) | $3.50 |
Cake
Chocolate Devil's Food, Yellow, Red Velvet, Carrot*, Lemon, Almond-Hazelnut* ^, Flourless Chocolate* ^
Filling
Swiss Meringue Buttercream (chocolate, vanilla, mocha, lemon, orange, white chocolate, pistachio*), Fresh Fruit & Cream, Cream Cheese Icing, Mousse (chocolate, white chocolate, fruit), Fruit Preserves (apricot, raspberry, strawberry, orange)
Icing
Swiss Meringue Buttercream (chocolate, vanilla, mocha, lemon, orange, white chocolate), Ganache, Chocolate Glaze, Cream Cheese Icing, Seven-Minute Icing. Marzipan* ^ and Rolled Fondant^ available at an additional charge. Please inquire
Handmade right here and straight from our oven - every morning. $3.50 each
Turnover
Cherry, Apple, Seasonal Fruit
Madeline's Muffin
Banana Nut^, Apple, Carrot Raisin, Oat Bran, Blueberry, Seasonal Fruit
Scone
Currant, Lemon, Apricot, Chocolate Chip, Pecan-Cranberry^, Orange-Pineapple, Lavender-Hazelnut^, Coconut-Lime, Caramelized Bacon
Danish
Cheese, Prune
Apricot Pinwheel
Buttery, flaky dough with an apricot jam center
Croissant
Butter, Almond^, Chocolate
Schnecken^
Traditional German breakfast spiral with frangipan and currants
Ring Ding
| $5.00 |
Mini Ring Ding
| $3.50 |
Lemon Tart
| $5.50 |
Mixed Berry Tart
| $5.50 |
Nut Cake^
| $5.50 |
Cheesecake
| $4.50 |
Éclair
| $4.50 |
Cupcake
| $3.50 |
Magic Cupcake™
| $5.00 |
Mini Cupcake
| $2.50 |
Bouchon
| $2.95 |
Fudge Brownie
| $3.95 |
Gluten-Free Fudge Brownie
| $3.95 |
Walnut Brownie^
| $4.50 |
Madeline's Best Lemon Cake
| $3.50 |
Opera Squares
| $5.00 |
Assorted Mini Butter Cookies^
1/2lb | $16.00 |
Small Homestyle Cookies
Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal, Peanut Butter^
1/2lb | $16.00 |
Chocolate Leaf Cookies^
1/2lb | $16.00 |
Macaroons
1/2lb | $16.00 |
Hand-Decorated Cookies
Starting At | $3.50 |
Daily Specials
Prices Vary |
$3 each, minimum order 12
Shapes
Round; Square; Oval; Heart
Flavors
Almond Pound Cake with Apricot or Raspberry Jam; Lemon Pound Cake with Lemon Curd; Chocolate Fudge Cake with Chocolate Filling
Glaze Colors
Pastel Yellow; Pastel Pink; Lavender; Pastel Blue; Mint Green; White, Red; Dark Chocolate. Custom Color +$0.50 per piece
Designs
Pinwheel; Gift Box; Daisy; Heart; Baroque Border; Monogrammed. Some designs are only available on certain shapes
Design Colors
Pastel Yellow; Pastel Pink; Lavender; Pastel Blue; Mint Green; White, Red; Dark Chocolate. Custom Color +$0.50 per piece
Finishes
Gold, Silver, Pearl +$0.50 per piece
$3.50 each regular size, $2.50 each mini size; minimum 12
Cake Batter
Chocolate Devil's Food; Yellow; Red Velvet; Carrot (contains nuts); Lemon
Icing
Swiss Meringue Buttercream; Ganache; Chocolate Glaze; Cream Cheese Icing; Seven-Minute Icing; Fondant Glaze
Topping
Chocolate Sprinkles; Rainbow Sprinkles; Gold Star Confetti; Silver Star Confetti; Pastel Colored Confetti; Primary Colored Confetti
6" (serves 6-8); 8" (serves 8-12)adults
Blackout Cake
Rich and perfectly moist chocolate cake filled with luscious chocolate mousse and glazed with flawless chocolate ganache icing. A chocolate triple crown!
6" | $38.00 |
8" | $48.00 |
Madeline's Favorite Flourless Cake^
A dense, gluten-free chocolate cake with a layer of raspberry jam, finished with a bittersweet chocolate glaze and dusted with edible gold. May also be inscribed with a personal message in gold
6" | $28.00 |
8" | $40.00 |
Cheesecake
Classic, creamy, utterly decadent New York style cheesecake. This is the real deal!
6" | $25.00 |
8" | $38.00 |
Nut Cake^
A moist almond and hazelnut cake with a layer of apricot jam, baked in a tart shell and finished with sliced almonds. A cake with enthusiastic devotees!
6" | $25.00 |
8" | $33.00 |
Lemon Tart
Our delicious, tangy lemon curd baked in a golden tart shell and decorated with delicate chocolate filigree. A cool, refreshing ending to any meal
6" | $25.00 |
8" | $34.00 |
Mixed Berry Tart
Juicy, flavorful, seasonal berries, topped with a spiced crumble topping and baked in a flaky shell
6" | $25.00 |
8" | $34.00 |
Seasonal Pies
Scrumptious tree fruits in the Autumn; sumptuous berries in the Summer. Just ask!
| $25.00 - $48.00 |