405 E Kirkwood Ave

Bloomington, IN 47408 - Monroe County

(812) 332-2111

Menu Highlights

Onion Rings


Salad with Mozzarella Cheese



our own unique pizza sauce over a layer of delicious seasoned sausage, with mozzarella cheese and onion, baked on a 10 in. loaf of italian bread and served with our homestyle pickles upon request

Whole 9.00
Half 4.50


choose up to 5 toppings!

16 In. 21.70
14 In. 16.70
10 In. 12.95
7 In. 7.75

BBQ Chicken Pizza

a blend of our famous pizza sauce and tangy BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, red onion, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses

16 In. 21.70
14 In. 16.70
10 In. 12.95
7 In. 7.75

About Cafe Pizzaria:

Opening it’s doors in February of 1953, Cafe Pizzaria was Bloomington’s first pizzeria. The menu consisted only of pizza, but their signature Hot Submarines and Strombolis were quickly added to the list of delicious menu items. Originally named “The Pizzaria” the name was changed to “Cafe Pizzaria” in the late-sixties. Cafe Pizzaria featured a full-service Mexican menu, “La Tortilla,” from 1967–71. A Spanish dungeon theme was used to decorate the back room of the restaurant, including: rod iron light fixtures, giant distressed beams on the ceiling, and whiskey barrels and kegs used as tables and chairs. Remnants of this decor remain in the restaurant. A second kitchen was added to prepare the Mexican food, now used to prepare our grilled sandwiches and burgers.

Categories: Restaurants/Food & Dining, Cafe Restaurants, Pizza Restaurant, Full-Service Restaurants, Restaurants: Cafes, Cafeterias & Lunchrooms, Eating Places, Cafes, Cafeterias & Lunchrooms and Restaurants

Specialties: American, American Food, American Restaurant

Product Features: Home Style, Italian, French Food, French Restaurant, Home Cooking, Home Style Food, Home Style Restaurant, Homemade, Italian Food, Italian Restaurant, French

Location Features: Dine In, Eat In, Seating, Sit Down

Products: Appetizers, Bacon, Beef, Breads, Cheeseburgers, Chicken, Chips, Coffee, Ham, Milk, Pizza, Rye, Salads, Sandwiches, Sausage, Soups, Steak, Vegetables, Ensalada, Finger Foods, Insalata, Java, Pizza Pie, Pollo, Snacks, Starters, Hors D'Oeuvres, Tea

Services: Catering

Payment Mode: Credit Card

Brands: Coca-Cola, Pepsi

Year Started: 1953

Map & Directions:

Reviews for Cafe Pizzaria:


QR Code:
Are You a Business Owner?
— or —
Add your Company for Free